Our Company

Our Mission

Mission Statement

Grow our business by building profitable relationships through excellence in risk management, claim advocacy, service and developing creative solutions.

Our Commitment

Earl Andres said it in 1923, and we remain faithful to a principle of, “service—to our customers, the community and each other.”

When it comes to community, our philosophy is simple: when a community is strong, everyone benefits. We believe in strengthening the communities we serve through philanthropy, employment opportunities and helping other local businesses succeed.

“Their dedication to providing and executing the highest quality of customer service and products is exemplary. They are a pleasure to work with and we look forward to fostering our business relationship in the future.”

Tammy Hantz, AgriDry

Meet Our Team

From the front office to our agents, AOL is staffed with caring, knowledgeable employees. We’re here to help you find coverage that brings peace of mind for the good times and protection for the tough times.

While we act locally, we think globally. Our leadership team is forward-thinking, exploring nearly every possible product and solution to see how it can benefit our local clients.

Agency Management

Kevin L Morton, CPIA
President
Archbold

Elizabeth H Pool, CBC, CPIA
Managing Partner
Bryan

Thomas Herman
Chairman of the Board
Bryan

Russell H Davies, CPIA
Managing Partner
Bryan

Mindy Hess
Chief Financial Officer
Bryan

Garrett Morton
Director of Client Services
Archbold

Commercial Lines

Eddie Partin, CPIA
Risk Advisor
Archbold

Stacy M Swary
Risk Advisor
Bryan

Vickie L Thiel, CPIA
Account Manager
Bryan

Jessica R Crocker
Account Manager
Archbold

Jen Mallett
Account Manager
Archbold

Scott Loy
Risk Advisor
Wauseon

Erin Elting
Commercial Lines CSR
Bryan

Dean Day
Risk Advisor
Bryan

Jim DeVantier
Risk Advisor
Bryan

Kathy Miller
Account Mananger
Bryan

McKenzie Nau
Risk Advisor
Bryan

Personal Lines

Melinda Robinson, CPIA
Risk Advisor
Wauseon

Tami L Bergman
Risk Advisor
Bryan

Angi Campos
Account Manager
Bryan

Janel D Rath
Account Manager
Bryan

Kate Cooper
Account Manager
Wauseon

Hillary Guilford
Account Manager
Bryan

Tori Herzog
Account Manager
Wauseon

Jordan L Short
Account Manager
Archbold

Mary Ann Schroeder
Claims Service Manager
Bryan

Carrie Dunson
Account Manager
Bryan

Lydia Fritch
Account Manager
Bryan

Cris Hendricks
Account Manager
Bryan

Rod McCrea
Account Manager
Bryan

Kay Vollmer
Account Manager
Bryan

Administration

Erin L Beals, CISR, CPIA
Operations Manager
Bryan

Cherri Meyer
Agency Assistant
Bryan

Holly Neubig
Accounting Assistant
Bryan

Tiffany Posey
Agency Assistant
Bryan

Heather Trowbridge
Agency Assistant
Bryan

Employee Benefits

Sarah R Derck
Account Manager
Bryan

Megan D Wyse, CBC, CPIA
Director of Compliance, Employee Benefits Manager
Archbold

Michelle Barnes
Customer Service Representative
Wauseon

“Our Company has been with Andres O’Neil for many years. The staff with Andres O’Neil has always stepped up to the plate and offered to research the problem, and never gave up until a firm answer was given. I myself and my husband underwent some major health problems. And as we know all insurance carriers will do anything in their power to find loopholes to not cover a procedure. With the great help of staff working on our behalf, they went above and beyond the call of duty to make phone calls and contact our carrier to get answers and even overturn decisions. Without the help of these ladies, we would not receive benefits and resolved our health issue. Andres O’Neil staff been wonderful to our needs over the years and I see many more years great service to come. We feel you get what you pay for. Thank You ladies!”

Jerelyn Spangler, Rapid Machine